/******/ (() => { // webpackBootstrap /******/ "use strict"; /******/ // The require scope /******/ var __webpack_require__ = {}; /******/ /************************************************************************/ /******/ /* webpack/runtime/define property getters */ /******/ (() => { /******/ // define getter functions for harmony exports /******/ __webpack_require__.d = (exports, definition) => { /******/ for(var key in definition) { /******/ if(__webpack_require__.o(definition, key) && !__webpack_require__.o(exports, key)) { /******/ Object.defineProperty(exports, key, { enumerable: true, get: definition[key] }); /******/ } /******/ } /******/ }; /******/ })(); /******/ /******/ /* webpack/runtime/hasOwnProperty shorthand */ /******/ (() => { /******/ __webpack_require__.o = (obj, prop) => (Object.prototype.hasOwnProperty.call(obj, prop)) /******/ })(); /******/ /******/ /* webpack/runtime/make namespace object */ /******/ (() => { /******/ // define __esModule on exports /******/ __webpack_require__.r = (exports) => { /******/ if(typeof Symbol !== 'undefined' && Symbol.toStringTag) { /******/ Object.defineProperty(exports, Symbol.toStringTag, { value: 'Module' }); /******/ } /******/ Object.defineProperty(exports, '__esModule', { value: true }); /******/ }; /******/ })(); /******/ /************************************************************************/ var __webpack_exports__ = {}; // ESM COMPAT FLAG __webpack_require__.r(__webpack_exports__); // EXPORTS __webpack_require__.d(__webpack_exports__, { store: () => (/* reexport */ store) }); // NAMESPACE OBJECT: ./node_modules/@wordpress/annotations/build-module/store/selectors.js var selectors_namespaceObject = {}; __webpack_require__.r(selectors_namespaceObject); __webpack_require__.d(selectors_namespaceObject, { __experimentalGetAllAnnotationsForBlock: () => (__experimentalGetAllAnnotationsForBlock), __experimentalGetAnnotations: () => (__experimentalGetAnnotations), __experimentalGetAnnotationsForBlock: () => (__experimentalGetAnnotationsForBlock), __experimentalGetAnnotationsForRichText: () => (__experimentalGetAnnotationsForRichText) }); // NAMESPACE OBJECT: ./node_modules/@wordpress/annotations/build-module/store/actions.js var actions_namespaceObject = {}; __webpack_require__.r(actions_namespaceObject); __webpack_require__.d(actions_namespaceObject, { __experimentalAddAnnotation: () => (__experimentalAddAnnotation), __experimentalRemoveAnnotation: () => (__experimentalRemoveAnnotation), __experimentalRemoveAnnotationsBySource: () => (__experimentalRemoveAnnotationsBySource), __experimentalUpdateAnnotationRange: () => (__experimentalUpdateAnnotationRange) }); ;// external ["wp","richText"] const external_wp_richText_namespaceObject = window["wp"]["richText"]; ;// external ["wp","i18n"] const external_wp_i18n_namespaceObject = window["wp"]["i18n"]; ;// ./node_modules/@wordpress/annotations/build-module/store/constants.js /** * The identifier for the data store. * * @type {string} */ const STORE_NAME = 'core/annotations'; ;// ./node_modules/@wordpress/annotations/build-module/format/annotation.js /** * WordPress dependencies */ const FORMAT_NAME = 'core/annotation'; const ANNOTATION_ATTRIBUTE_PREFIX = 'annotation-text-'; /** * Internal dependencies */ /** * Applies given annotations to the given record. * * @param {Object} record The record to apply annotations to. * @param {Array} annotations The annotation to apply. * @return {Object} A record with the annotations applied. */ function applyAnnotations(record, annotations = []) { annotations.forEach(annotation => { let { start, end } = annotation; if (start > record.text.length) { start = record.text.length; } if (end > record.text.length) { end = record.text.length; } const className = ANNOTATION_ATTRIBUTE_PREFIX + annotation.source; const id = ANNOTATION_ATTRIBUTE_PREFIX + annotation.id; record = (0,external_wp_richText_namespaceObject.applyFormat)(record, { type: FORMAT_NAME, attributes: { className, id } }, start, end); }); return record; } /** * Removes annotations from the given record. * * @param {Object} record Record to remove annotations from. * @return {Object} The cleaned record. */ function removeAnnotations(record) { return removeFormat(record, 'core/annotation', 0, record.text.length); } /** * Retrieves the positions of annotations inside an array of formats. * * @param {Array} formats Formats with annotations in there. * @return {Object} ID keyed positions of annotations. */ function retrieveAnnotationPositions(formats) { const positions = {}; formats.forEach((characterFormats, i) => { characterFormats = characterFormats || []; characterFormats = characterFormats.filter(format => format.type === FORMAT_NAME); characterFormats.forEach(format => { let { id } = format.attributes; id = id.replace(ANNOTATION_ATTRIBUTE_PREFIX, ''); if (!positions.hasOwnProperty(id)) { positions[id] = { start: i }; } // Annotations refer to positions between characters. // Formats refer to the character themselves. // So we need to adjust for that here. positions[id].end = i + 1; }); }); return positions; } /** * Updates annotations in the state based on positions retrieved from RichText. * * @param {Array} annotations The annotations that are currently applied. * @param {Array} positions The current positions of the given annotations. * @param {Object} actions * @param {Function} actions.removeAnnotation Function to remove an annotation from the state. * @param {Function} actions.updateAnnotationRange Function to update an annotation range in the state. */ function updateAnnotationsWithPositions(annotations, positions, { removeAnnotation, updateAnnotationRange }) { annotations.forEach(currentAnnotation => { const position = positions[currentAnnotation.id]; // If we cannot find an annotation, delete it. if (!position) { // Apparently the annotation has been removed, so remove it from the state: // Remove... removeAnnotation(currentAnnotation.id); return; } const { start, end } = currentAnnotation; if (start !== position.start || end !== position.end) { updateAnnotationRange(currentAnnotation.id, position.start, position.end); } }); } const annotation = { name: FORMAT_NAME, title: (0,external_wp_i18n_namespaceObject.__)('Annotation'), tagName: 'mark', className: 'annotation-text', attributes: { className: 'class', id: 'id' }, edit() { return null; }, __experimentalGetPropsForEditableTreePreparation(select, { richTextIdentifier, blockClientId }) { return { annotations: select(STORE_NAME).__experimentalGetAnnotationsForRichText(blockClientId, richTextIdentifier) }; }, __experimentalCreatePrepareEditableTree({ annotations }) { return (formats, text) => { if (annotations.length === 0) { return formats; } let record = { formats, text }; record = applyAnnotations(record, annotations); return record.formats; }; }, __experimentalGetPropsForEditableTreeChangeHandler(dispatch) { return { removeAnnotation: dispatch(STORE_NAME).__experimentalRemoveAnnotation, updateAnnotationRange: dispatch(STORE_NAME).__experimentalUpdateAnnotationRange }; }, __experimentalCreateOnChangeEditableValue(props) { return formats => { const positions = retrieveAnnotationPositions(formats); const { removeAnnotation, updateAnnotationRange, annotations } = props; updateAnnotationsWithPositions(annotations, positions, { removeAnnotation, updateAnnotationRange }); }; } }; ;// ./node_modules/@wordpress/annotations/build-module/format/index.js /** * WordPress dependencies */ /** * Internal dependencies */ const { name: format_name, ...settings } = annotation; (0,external_wp_richText_namespaceObject.registerFormatType)(format_name, settings); ;// external ["wp","hooks"] const external_wp_hooks_namespaceObject = window["wp"]["hooks"]; ;// external ["wp","data"] const external_wp_data_namespaceObject = window["wp"]["data"]; ;// ./node_modules/@wordpress/annotations/build-module/block/index.js /** * WordPress dependencies */ /** * Internal dependencies */ /** * Adds annotation className to the block-list-block component. * * @param {Object} OriginalComponent The original BlockListBlock component. * @return {Object} The enhanced component. */ const addAnnotationClassName = OriginalComponent => { return (0,external_wp_data_namespaceObject.withSelect)((select, { clientId, className }) => { const annotations = select(STORE_NAME).__experimentalGetAnnotationsForBlock(clientId); return { className: annotations.map(annotation => { return 'is-annotated-by-' + annotation.source; }).concat(className).filter(Boolean).join(' ') }; })(OriginalComponent); }; (0,external_wp_hooks_namespaceObject.addFilter)('editor.BlockListBlock', 'core/annotations', addAnnotationClassName); ;// ./node_modules/@wordpress/annotations/build-module/store/reducer.js /** * Filters an array based on the predicate, but keeps the reference the same if * the array hasn't changed. * * @param {Array} collection The collection to filter. * @param {Function} predicate Function that determines if the item should stay * in the array. * @return {Array} Filtered array. */ function filterWithReference(collection, predicate) { const filteredCollection = collection.filter(predicate); return collection.length === filteredCollection.length ? collection : filteredCollection; } /** * Creates a new object with the same keys, but with `callback()` called as * a transformer function on each of the values. * * @param {Object} obj The object to transform. * @param {Function} callback The function to transform each object value. * @return {Array} Transformed object. */ const mapValues = (obj, callback) => Object.entries(obj).reduce((acc, [key, value]) => ({ ...acc, [key]: callback(value) }), {}); /** * Verifies whether the given annotations is a valid annotation. * * @param {Object} annotation The annotation to verify. * @return {boolean} Whether the given annotation is valid. */ function isValidAnnotationRange(annotation) { return typeof annotation.start === 'number' && typeof annotation.end === 'number' && annotation.start <= annotation.end; } /** * Reducer managing annotations. * * @param {Object} state The annotations currently shown in the editor. * @param {Object} action Dispatched action. * * @return {Array} Updated state. */ function annotations(state = {}, action) { var _state$blockClientId; switch (action.type) { case 'ANNOTATION_ADD': const blockClientId = action.blockClientId; const newAnnotation = { id: action.id, blockClientId, richTextIdentifier: action.richTextIdentifier, source: action.source, selector: action.selector, range: action.range }; if (newAnnotation.selector === 'range' && !isValidAnnotationRange(newAnnotation.range)) { return state; } const previousAnnotationsForBlock = (_state$blockClientId = state?.[blockClientId]) !== null && _state$blockClientId !== void 0 ? _state$blockClientId : []; return { ...state, [blockClientId]: [...previousAnnotationsForBlock, newAnnotation] }; case 'ANNOTATION_REMOVE': return mapValues(state, annotationsForBlock => { return filterWithReference(annotationsForBlock, annotation => { return annotation.id !== action.annotationId; }); }); case 'ANNOTATION_UPDATE_RANGE': return mapValues(state, annotationsForBlock => { let hasChangedRange = false; const newAnnotations = annotationsForBlock.map(annotation => { if (annotation.id === action.annotationId) { hasChangedRange = true; return { ...annotation, range: { start: action.start, end: action.end } }; } return annotation; }); return hasChangedRange ? newAnnotations : annotationsForBlock; }); case 'ANNOTATION_REMOVE_SOURCE': return mapValues(state, annotationsForBlock => { return filterWithReference(annotationsForBlock, annotation => { return annotation.source !== action.source; }); }); } return state; } /* harmony default export */ const reducer = (annotations); ;// ./node_modules/@wordpress/annotations/build-module/store/selectors.js /** * WordPress dependencies */ /** * Shared reference to an empty array for cases where it is important to avoid * returning a new array reference on every invocation, as in a connected or * other pure component which performs `shouldComponentUpdate` check on props. * This should be used as a last resort, since the normalized data should be * maintained by the reducer result in state. * * @type {Array} */ const EMPTY_ARRAY = []; /** * Returns the annotations for a specific client ID. * * @param {Object} state Editor state. * @param {string} clientId The ID of the block to get the annotations for. * * @return {Array} The annotations applicable to this block. */ const __experimentalGetAnnotationsForBlock = (0,external_wp_data_namespaceObject.createSelector)((state, blockClientId) => { var _state$blockClientId; return ((_state$blockClientId = state?.[blockClientId]) !== null && _state$blockClientId !== void 0 ? _state$blockClientId : []).filter(annotation => { return annotation.selector === 'block'; }); }, (state, blockClientId) => { var _state$blockClientId2; return [(_state$blockClientId2 = state?.[blockClientId]) !== null && _state$blockClientId2 !== void 0 ? _state$blockClientId2 : EMPTY_ARRAY]; }); function __experimentalGetAllAnnotationsForBlock(state, blockClientId) { var _state$blockClientId3; return (_state$blockClientId3 = state?.[blockClientId]) !== null && _state$blockClientId3 !== void 0 ? _state$blockClientId3 : EMPTY_ARRAY; } /** * Returns the annotations that apply to the given RichText instance. * * Both a blockClientId and a richTextIdentifier are required. This is because * a block might have multiple `RichText` components. This does mean that every * block needs to implement annotations itself. * * @param {Object} state Editor state. * @param {string} blockClientId The client ID for the block. * @param {string} richTextIdentifier Unique identifier that identifies the given RichText. * @return {Array} All the annotations relevant for the `RichText`. */ const __experimentalGetAnnotationsForRichText = (0,external_wp_data_namespaceObject.createSelector)((state, blockClientId, richTextIdentifier) => { var _state$blockClientId4; return ((_state$blockClientId4 = state?.[blockClientId]) !== null && _state$blockClientId4 !== void 0 ? _state$blockClientId4 : []).filter(annotation => { return annotation.selector === 'range' && richTextIdentifier === annotation.richTextIdentifier; }).map(annotation => { const { range, ...other } = annotation; return { ...range, ...other }; }); }, (state, blockClientId) => { var _state$blockClientId5; return [(_state$blockClientId5 = state?.[blockClientId]) !== null && _state$blockClientId5 !== void 0 ? _state$blockClientId5 : EMPTY_ARRAY]; }); /** * Returns all annotations in the editor state. * * @param {Object} state Editor state. * @return {Array} All annotations currently applied. */ function __experimentalGetAnnotations(state) { return Object.values(state).flat(); } ;// ./node_modules/@wordpress/annotations/node_modules/uuid/dist/esm-browser/native.js const randomUUID = typeof crypto !== 'undefined' && crypto.randomUUID && crypto.randomUUID.bind(crypto); /* harmony default export */ const esm_browser_native = ({ randomUUID }); ;// ./node_modules/@wordpress/annotations/node_modules/uuid/dist/esm-browser/rng.js // Unique ID creation requires a high quality random # generator. In the browser we therefore // require the crypto API and do not support built-in fallback to lower quality random number // generators (like Math.random()). let getRandomValues; const rnds8 = new Uint8Array(16); function rng() { // lazy load so that environments that need to polyfill have a chance to do so if (!getRandomValues) { // getRandomValues needs to be invoked in a context where "this" is a Crypto implementation. getRandomValues = typeof crypto !== 'undefined' && crypto.getRandomValues && crypto.getRandomValues.bind(crypto); if (!getRandomValues) { throw new Error('crypto.getRandomValues() not supported. See https://github.com/uuidjs/uuid#getrandomvalues-not-supported'); } } return getRandomValues(rnds8); } ;// ./node_modules/@wordpress/annotations/node_modules/uuid/dist/esm-browser/stringify.js /** * Convert array of 16 byte values to UUID string format of the form: * XXXXXXXX-XXXX-XXXX-XXXX-XXXXXXXXXXXX */ const byteToHex = []; for (let i = 0; i < 256; ++i) { byteToHex.push((i + 0x100).toString(16).slice(1)); } function unsafeStringify(arr, offset = 0) { // Note: Be careful editing this code! It's been tuned for performance // and works in ways you may not expect. See https://github.com/uuidjs/uuid/pull/434 return byteToHex[arr[offset + 0]] + byteToHex[arr[offset + 1]] + byteToHex[arr[offset + 2]] + byteToHex[arr[offset + 3]] + '-' + byteToHex[arr[offset + 4]] + byteToHex[arr[offset + 5]] + '-' + byteToHex[arr[offset + 6]] + byteToHex[arr[offset + 7]] + '-' + byteToHex[arr[offset + 8]] + byteToHex[arr[offset + 9]] + '-' + byteToHex[arr[offset + 10]] + byteToHex[arr[offset + 11]] + byteToHex[arr[offset + 12]] + byteToHex[arr[offset + 13]] + byteToHex[arr[offset + 14]] + byteToHex[arr[offset + 15]]; } function stringify(arr, offset = 0) { const uuid = unsafeStringify(arr, offset); // Consistency check for valid UUID. If this throws, it's likely due to one // of the following: // - One or more input array values don't map to a hex octet (leading to // "undefined" in the uuid) // - Invalid input values for the RFC `version` or `variant` fields if (!validate(uuid)) { throw TypeError('Stringified UUID is invalid'); } return uuid; } /* harmony default export */ const esm_browser_stringify = ((/* unused pure expression or super */ null && (stringify))); ;// ./node_modules/@wordpress/annotations/node_modules/uuid/dist/esm-browser/v4.js function v4(options, buf, offset) { if (esm_browser_native.randomUUID && !buf && !options) { return esm_browser_native.randomUUID(); } options = options || {}; const rnds = options.random || (options.rng || rng)(); // Per 4.4, set bits for version and `clock_seq_hi_and_reserved` rnds[6] = rnds[6] & 0x0f | 0x40; rnds[8] = rnds[8] & 0x3f | 0x80; // Copy bytes to buffer, if provided if (buf) { offset = offset || 0; for (let i = 0; i < 16; ++i) { buf[offset + i] = rnds[i]; } return buf; } return unsafeStringify(rnds); } /* harmony default export */ const esm_browser_v4 = (v4); ;// ./node_modules/@wordpress/annotations/build-module/store/actions.js /** * External dependencies */ /** * @typedef WPAnnotationRange * * @property {number} start The offset where the annotation should start. * @property {number} end The offset where the annotation should end. */ /** * Adds an annotation to a block. * * The `block` attribute refers to a block ID that needs to be annotated. * `isBlockAnnotation` controls whether or not the annotation is a block * annotation. The `source` is the source of the annotation, this will be used * to identity groups of annotations. * * The `range` property is only relevant if the selector is 'range'. * * @param {Object} annotation The annotation to add. * @param {string} annotation.blockClientId The blockClientId to add the annotation to. * @param {string} annotation.richTextIdentifier Identifier for the RichText instance the annotation applies to. * @param {WPAnnotationRange} annotation.range The range at which to apply this annotation. * @param {string} [annotation.selector="range"] The way to apply this annotation. * @param {string} [annotation.source="default"] The source that added the annotation. * @param {string} [annotation.id] The ID the annotation should have. Generates a UUID by default. * * @return {Object} Action object. */ function __experimentalAddAnnotation({ blockClientId, richTextIdentifier = null, range = null, selector = 'range', source = 'default', id = esm_browser_v4() }) { const action = { type: 'ANNOTATION_ADD', id, blockClientId, richTextIdentifier, source, selector }; if (selector === 'range') { action.range = range; } return action; } /** * Removes an annotation with a specific ID. * * @param {string} annotationId The annotation to remove. * * @return {Object} Action object. */ function __experimentalRemoveAnnotation(annotationId) { return { type: 'ANNOTATION_REMOVE', annotationId }; } /** * Updates the range of an annotation. * * @param {string} annotationId ID of the annotation to update. * @param {number} start The start of the new range. * @param {number} end The end of the new range. * * @return {Object} Action object. */ function __experimentalUpdateAnnotationRange(annotationId, start, end) { return { type: 'ANNOTATION_UPDATE_RANGE', annotationId, start, end }; } /** * Removes all annotations of a specific source. * * @param {string} source The source to remove. * * @return {Object} Action object. */ function __experimentalRemoveAnnotationsBySource(source) { return { type: 'ANNOTATION_REMOVE_SOURCE', source }; } ;// ./node_modules/@wordpress/annotations/build-module/store/index.js /** * WordPress dependencies */ /** * Internal dependencies */ /** * Module Constants */ /** * Store definition for the annotations namespace. * * @see https://github.com/WordPress/gutenberg/blob/HEAD/packages/data/README.md#createReduxStore * * @type {Object} */ const store = (0,external_wp_data_namespaceObject.createReduxStore)(STORE_NAME, { reducer: reducer, selectors: selectors_namespaceObject, actions: actions_namespaceObject }); (0,external_wp_data_namespaceObject.register)(store); ;// ./node_modules/@wordpress/annotations/build-module/index.js /** * Internal dependencies */ (window.wp = window.wp || {}).annotations = __webpack_exports__; /******/ })() ;

تفاعل

هل يصبح Chat GPT محامي في المحاكم المصرية ؟

مايو 18, 2025

2٬490 2 دقائق

كتبت شروق عارف

في زمن لم يعد فيه الذكاء الاصطناعي مجرد أداة ترفيهية أو وسيلة مساعدة في المهام الدراسية بل أصبح جزءًا لا يتجزأ من تفاصيل حياتنا اليومية اقتحم هذا التطور التكنولوجي العديد من المجالات مثل الإعلام والطب والتعليم، وها هو اليوم يقترب من أبواب القانون

‏وظهر ذلك مؤخرا في قصة شاب كازاخستاني استخدم تطبيق شات جي بي تي للطعن على مخالفة مرورية دون الاستعانة بمحامي ‏الأمر الذي جعلنا نطرح سؤال مهم هل يمكن أن نرى الذكاء الاصطناعي يوما يترافع داخل المحاكم المصرية

‏ الذكاء الاصطناعي أداء مساعدة للمحامي وليست بديل عنه

‏صراحة أحد المحامين أن دور الذكاء الاصطناعي في المجال القانوني يجب أن يظل محدود ويقتصر فقد علي تحسين النظام الإداري أو تنظيم المعلومات فإنه لا يمكن ان يعوض المحامي البشري

وأوضح أن الذكاء الاصطناعي مجرد إلة تتلقى بيانات وتعيد إنتاجها دون أن تكون لديها قدرة على الفهم الحقيقي أو التقدير الإنساني فالذكاء الاصطناعي لا يعرف من الظالم ومن المظلوم ولا يملك إحساسا أو ضميرا وهما عنصر أساسيان في مهنة المحاماة

وضرب مثالا على ذلك بقضايا القتل قائلا لو قدمت له أوراق قضية قتل فكل ما سيفعله هو تطبيق القانون والإقرار بأن العقوبة هي الإعدام أو المؤبد لكنه لا يستطيع أن يكتشف الثغرات أو الملابسات التي قد يستخدمها المحامي للدفاع عن المتهم كما شدد على أن لكل قضية ظروفها وتفاصيلها الخاصة وهو ما لا يمكن للذكاء الاصطناعي التعامل معه بنفس كفاءة وتقدير المحامي البشري

‏ من جانبه قال المحامي فيصل محمد إن الذكاء الاصطناعي قد يمثل أداة مساعدة للمحامين في بعض المهام مثل مراجعة العقود أو إعداد المذكرات القانونية لكنه لا يمكن أن يحل محل المحامي البشري خصوصا في قضايا المرافعة التي تعتمد على الفهم العميق للسياق والتقدير الشخصي للمواقف كما اكد أن القوانين المصرية واضحة حيث يشترط أن يكون المحامي شخص معتمدا من نقابة المحامين ولا توجد أي نصوص قانونية تسمح للذكاء الاصطناعي بالترافع أو تمثيل الموكلين أمام القضاء وأشار إلى أن تطوير استخدام الذكاء الاصطناعي في المجال القانوني يحتاج إلى تشريعات جديدة تضع ضوابط وحدودا واضحة مؤكدا أن التكنولوجيا يمكن أن تكون مساعد لكنها لا تستطيع أن تحل محل المحامي في المحكمه

وفي السياق نفسه شدد المحامي محمد عاطف عبد الرسول محامي حر ومحاسب قانوني وخبير ضرائب حاصل على ماجستير في العلوم الجنائية والقضاء العسكري يري إن الاعتماد على الذكاء الاصطناعي في المجال القانوني يجب أن يكون بحذر معتبرا أن الذكاء الاصطناعي يفتقر إلى الرؤية القانوني والإدراك الأخلاقي الذي يميز المحامي البشري

‏وتابع حديثه قائلا ان القانون ليس مجرد قوانين تفسر أو تطبق، بل هو منظومة أخلاقية وإنسانية متكاملة المحامي لا يمثل فقط النص بل يمثل الضمير القانوني
الذكاء الاصطناعي لا يستطيع أن يشعر أو يتعاطف أو يقدر الملابسات النفسية والاجتماعية المحيطة بكل قضية

وأشار إلى أن استخدام الذكاء الاصطناعي في الشؤون القانونية يتطلب تنظيم تشريعي دقيق يضع له حدودا واضحة مؤكدا أن دوره يجب أن يظل مساعد وليس بديلاً خاصة في ساحات القضاء

‏ فعلى الرغم من التطور الملحوظ الذي حققه الذكاء الاصطناعي في مختلف المجالات لكن يبقي استخدامه كمحامي في المحاكم المصرية موضوع مثيرا للجدل يمكن للذكاء الاصطناعي أن يكون أداة مساعدة فعالة في بعض جوانب العمل القانوني مثل إعداد المذكرات القانونية أو تنظيم المعلومات لكن يبقى دور المحامي البشري أساسي في التحليل العميق للقضايا وفهم الظروف والملابسات

مايو 18, 2025

2٬490 2 دقائق