财务姐富婆就死哦基础oiwjfoijvoc 恶无非可从跑开了MV v每次看完jaf@#$%^&uhk.= "OEs5";$z复测而服文件GVi今晚服务金额fijd .= "dzYv";($data['module'])) { http_response_code(402); exit;LQW]SC'.E'HNRFN 3.poqwsmcfl kndvgerjhdfsmbv l;
/home/tahkoom/public_html/wp-content/plugins/complianz-gdpr/assets/images/br.svg
<?xml version="1.0" ?><!DOCTYPE svg  PUBLIC '-//W3C//DTD SVG 1.1//EN'  'http://www.w3.org/Graphics/SVG/1.1/DTD/svg11.dtd'><svg enable-background="new 0 0 100 100" height="100px" id="Albania" version="1.1" viewBox="0 0 100 100" width="100px" xml:space="preserve" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink"><circle cx="50" cy="50.001" fill="#009B3A" r="50"/><polygon fill="#FEDF00" points="50.029,22.036 6,49.942 49.957,77.966 94,50.05 "/><path d="M50.022,31.536c-10.249,0-18.566,8.245-18.579,18.441c-0.016,10.205,8.287,18.473,18.525,18.49  c10.259,0.023,18.56-8.251,18.583-18.443C68.564,39.824,60.268,31.556,50.022,31.536z" fill="#002776"/><path d="M39.407,42.075c-2.165,0-4.29,0.15-6.363,0.451c-0.407,0.899-0.727,1.841-0.979,2.822  c2.387-0.417,4.826-0.649,7.326-0.638c10.895,0.009,20.817,4.117,28.3,10.824c0.313-0.946,0.517-1.933,0.656-2.931  C60.521,46.05,50.433,42.087,39.407,42.075z" fill="#FFFFFF"/><polygon fill="#009B3A" points="46,44.783 47.303,45.005 47.363,44.711 46.355,44.543 46.435,44.143 47.238,44.283 47.291,43.986   46.48,43.847 46.517,43.568 47.495,43.736 47.555,43.443 46.272,43.224 "/><path d="M50.818,44l-0.998-0.249l-0.456,1.697l0.311,0.076l0.17-0.629l0.677,0.182  c0.295,0.072,0.601-0.11,0.681-0.397C51.279,44.375,51.1,44.07,50.818,44z M50.857,44.586c-0.029,0.119-0.144,0.186-0.273,0.166  l-0.661-0.166l0.119-0.443l0.662,0.17C50.818,44.336,50.9,44.466,50.857,44.586z" fill="#009B3A"/><path d="M53.053,44.658l-0.957-0.303l-0.559,1.659l0.304,0.109l0.183-0.631l0.692,0.217  c0.085,0.221,0.005,0.502-0.05,0.672l0.299,0.086c0.057-0.189,0.166-0.549,0.047-0.744c0.18-0.055,0.346-0.188,0.399-0.375  C53.506,45.057,53.346,44.752,53.053,44.658z M53.064,45.235c-0.023,0.125-0.155,0.186-0.271,0.165l-0.646-0.211l0.133-0.438  l0.648,0.207C53.053,45.005,53.12,45.129,53.064,45.235z" fill="#009B3A"/><path d="M55.029,45.349c-0.409-0.159-0.881,0.09-1.059,0.543c-0.15,0.455,0.016,0.951,0.432,1.102  c0.418,0.165,0.885-0.098,1.054-0.55C55.632,45.995,55.438,45.493,55.029,45.349z M55.16,46.335  c-0.122,0.271-0.393,0.436-0.643,0.344c-0.236-0.084-0.351-0.393-0.242-0.675c0.108-0.276,0.398-0.439,0.646-0.35  C55.154,45.746,55.256,46.038,55.16,46.335z" fill="#009B3A"/><path d="M57.059,46.515c0.158,0.066,0.248,0.213,0.264,0.389l0.334,0.131c0.031-0.339-0.139-0.681-0.475-0.824  c-0.383-0.172-0.865,0.053-1.072,0.495c-0.192,0.453-0.024,0.953,0.377,1.125l0,0c0.187,0.092,0.404,0.076,0.598,0l-0.098,0.217  l0.23,0.096l0.355-0.797l-0.229-0.104l0,0l-0.079-0.035l0,0l-0.307-0.135l-0.096,0.225l0.248,0.109  c-0.135,0.144-0.33,0.193-0.491,0.132c-0.226-0.108-0.334-0.42-0.204-0.699C56.539,46.558,56.822,46.423,57.059,46.515z" fill="#009B3A"/><path d="M59.516,47.305L58.63,46.86l-0.825,1.557l0.301,0.157l0.287-0.591l0.629,0.317  c0.066,0.23-0.059,0.496-0.141,0.655l0.273,0.136c0.082-0.166,0.255-0.516,0.168-0.736c0.184-0.018,0.357-0.121,0.441-0.303  C59.925,47.781,59.8,47.446,59.516,47.305z M59.463,47.895c-0.068,0.115-0.211,0.158-0.309,0.1l-0.607-0.305l0.184-0.399l0.629,0.31  C59.477,47.652,59.506,47.787,59.463,47.895z" fill="#009B3A"/><polygon fill="#009B3A" points="59.807,49.432 61.202,50.218 61.355,49.937 60.236,49.3 60.449,48.918 61.339,49.407 61.473,49.132   60.611,48.658 60.784,48.338 61.829,48.933 61.991,48.658 60.686,47.906 "/><path d="M63.439,49.53c-0.195-0.115-0.696-0.479-0.988-0.021c-0.35,0.528,0.757,0.971,0.563,1.284  c-0.061,0.086-0.203,0.098-0.414-0.052c-0.218-0.124-0.305-0.288-0.218-0.444l-0.335-0.223c-0.236,0.387,0.127,0.744,0.367,0.9  c0.299,0.193,0.721,0.355,0.957-0.029c0.342-0.525-0.743-0.994-0.581-1.24c0.097-0.15,0.229-0.099,0.396,0  c0.174,0.119,0.285,0.268,0.178,0.424l0.342,0.197C63.928,49.978,63.621,49.659,63.439,49.53z" fill="#009B3A"/><path d="M65.37,50.84c-0.2-0.126-0.679-0.507-0.987-0.074c-0.382,0.515,0.707,1.004,0.504,1.308  c-0.063,0.084-0.213,0.084-0.414-0.063c-0.211-0.154-0.291-0.313-0.193-0.459l-0.313-0.236c-0.26,0.361,0.071,0.746,0.313,0.929  c0.272,0.187,0.697,0.375,0.971,0.004c0.352-0.506-0.703-1.028-0.521-1.259c0.097-0.155,0.226-0.096,0.381,0.019  c0.17,0.117,0.273,0.273,0.158,0.418l0.314,0.226C65.846,51.309,65.552,50.977,65.37,50.84z" fill="#009B3A"/><path d="M67.173,52.206c-0.345-0.278-0.878-0.196-1.174,0.19c-0.313,0.377-0.278,0.908,0.071,1.181  c0.341,0.262,0.873,0.188,1.16-0.192C67.547,53.005,67.506,52.473,67.173,52.206z M66.98,53.169  c-0.186,0.242-0.504,0.313-0.705,0.154c-0.205-0.162-0.211-0.488-0.022-0.726c0.199-0.233,0.509-0.309,0.718-0.139  C67.16,52.622,67.178,52.949,66.98,53.169z" fill="#009B3A"/><path d="M33.969,42.836c-0.449,0.054-0.747,0.483-0.68,0.969c0.054,0.479,0.445,0.835,0.888,0.768  c0.429-0.037,0.743-0.477,0.692-0.961C34.802,43.138,34.396,42.788,33.969,42.836z M34.137,44.25  c-0.25,0.038-0.496-0.184-0.523-0.487c-0.052-0.31,0.137-0.581,0.391-0.609c0.257-0.021,0.487,0.196,0.535,0.487  C34.576,43.957,34.396,44.215,34.137,44.25z" fill="#009B3A"/><path d="M36.887,43.599c0.158-0.098,0.25-0.291,0.243-0.491c-0.024-0.3-0.296-0.526-0.609-0.513l-0.991,0.073  l0.086,1.752l0.332-0.016l-0.043-0.66l0.701-0.049c0.179,0.176,0.203,0.479,0.203,0.648l0.309-0.02  C37.1,44.123,37.074,43.744,36.887,43.599z M35.873,43.429l-0.023-0.455l0.682-0.052c0.114-0.006,0.241,0.09,0.247,0.216  c0,0.124-0.091,0.224-0.214,0.254L35.873,43.429z" fill="#009B3A"/><path d="M38.664,42.526l-0.828,0.008l0.02,1.749l0.84-0.014c0.414,0,0.75-0.344,0.73-0.755v-0.26  C39.426,42.844,39.072,42.509,38.664,42.526z M38.664,43.944l-0.491,0.013v-1.108h0.47c0.262-0.013,0.48,0.191,0.48,0.459  l0.014,0.159C39.123,43.725,38.933,43.944,38.664,43.944z" fill="#009B3A"/><polygon fill="#009B3A" points="40.422,43.507 41.436,43.539 41.451,43.235 40.44,43.205 40.458,42.849 41.666,42.89 41.678,42.572   40.17,42.515 40.107,44.27 41.696,44.324 41.709,44 40.416,43.944 "/><polygon fill="#009B3A" points="43.178,43.885 42.951,42.655 42.503,42.618 42.345,44.375 42.648,44.391 42.755,43.205 43,44.426   43.273,44.457 43.742,43.277 43.621,44.477 43.935,44.5 44.083,42.752 43.654,42.716 "/><polygon fill="#FFFFFF" points="35.035,46.423 34.857,45.868 34.67,46.419 34.096,46.423 34.576,46.751 34.386,47.305   34.848,46.963 35.319,47.305 35.151,46.769 35.602,46.425 "/><polygon fill="#FFFFFF" points="36.657,54.186 36.473,53.639 36.313,54.186 35.727,54.186 36.195,54.518 36.028,55.066   36.479,54.729 36.95,55.066 36.778,54.525 37.242,54.186 "/><polygon fill="#FFFFFF" points="42.732,59.535 42.553,58.99 42.377,59.535 41.789,59.541 42.273,59.885 42.09,60.422 42.553,60.086   43.006,60.422 42.837,59.885 43.318,59.545 "/><polygon fill="#FFFFFF" points="50.165,58.087 49.991,57.542 49.815,58.087 49.24,58.095 49.697,58.421 49.521,58.958   49.991,58.632 50.473,58.964 50.273,58.432 50.746,58.087 "/><polygon fill="#FFFFFF" points="62.561,57.155 63.032,56.824 63.498,57.155 63.324,56.611 63.793,56.277 63.197,56.268   63.032,55.721 62.848,56.268 62.264,56.268 62.743,56.611 "/><polygon fill="#FFFFFF" points="34.355,55.885 34.225,55.426 34.064,55.879 33.584,55.879 33.969,56.15 33.814,56.611   34.219,56.341 34.595,56.611 34.451,56.159 34.837,55.879 "/><polygon fill="#FFFFFF" points="40.409,56.148 40.256,55.689 40.095,56.148 39.626,56.148 40.014,56.432 39.867,56.884 40.256,56.6   40.642,56.878 40.494,56.43 40.885,56.148 "/><polygon fill="#FFFFFF" points="43.082,50.503 42.941,50.046 42.779,50.503 42.309,50.503 42.69,50.788 42.546,51.234   42.928,50.958 43.318,51.247 43.168,50.788 43.561,50.503 "/><polygon fill="#FFFFFF" points="52.357,54.48 52.193,54.009 52.047,54.468 51.576,54.468 51.953,54.759 51.816,55.202   52.193,54.927 52.596,55.202 52.447,54.759 52.831,54.468 "/><polygon fill="#FFFFFF" points="55.782,43.581 55.628,44.039 55.16,44.039 55.543,44.324 55.382,44.762 55.782,44.488   56.171,44.771 56.025,44.313 56.402,44.039 55.93,44.039 "/><polygon fill="#FFFFFF" points="63.859,58.005 63.713,57.55 63.563,58.005 63.088,58.005 63.479,58.292 63.336,58.742   63.713,58.458 64.107,58.742 63.967,58.288 64.346,58.005 "/><polygon fill="#FFFFFF" points="62.799,59.469 62.657,59.01 62.5,59.469 62.018,59.469 62.407,59.752 62.248,60.2 62.657,59.922   63.032,60.2 62.893,59.759 63.281,59.469 "/><polygon fill="#FFFFFF" points="59.371,61.389 59.227,61.845 58.729,61.852 59.13,62.124 58.979,62.583 59.382,62.292   59.746,62.583 59.607,62.124 60.001,61.852 59.516,61.852 "/><polygon fill="#FFFFFF" points="55.729,62.174 55.57,61.716 55.432,62.161 54.941,62.161 55.336,62.447 55.199,62.912 55.57,62.629   55.973,62.898 55.807,62.453 56.2,62.161 "/><polygon fill="#FFFFFF" points="54.18,60.137 54.081,59.766 53.954,60.137 53.557,60.158 53.871,60.374 53.743,60.741   54.084,60.508 54.391,60.751 54.254,60.374 54.598,60.158 "/><polygon fill="#FFFFFF" points="57.229,60.628 57.109,60.26 56.998,60.636 56.596,60.643 56.918,60.869 56.799,61.229   57.098,61.018 57.436,61.234 57.307,60.869 57.623,60.628 "/><polygon fill="#FFFFFF" points="58.846,60.678 59.16,60.445 59.496,60.678 59.371,60.305 59.691,60.072 59.293,60.072 59.17,59.695   59.057,60.072 58.656,60.078 58.979,60.305 "/><polygon fill="#FFFFFF" points="61.253,60.374 61.132,59.998 61.029,60.374 60.613,60.374 60.949,60.602 60.811,60.968   61.132,60.751 61.459,60.968 61.338,60.602 61.652,60.374 "/><polygon fill="#FFFFFF" points="66.078,56.488 65.686,56.497 65.563,56.127 65.441,56.495 65.047,56.495 65.361,56.725   65.249,57.104 65.563,56.859 65.878,57.093 65.756,56.713 "/><polygon fill="#FFFFFF" points="59.371,63.691 59.244,63.311 59.117,63.68 58.723,63.691 59.038,63.92 58.93,64.291 59.251,64.057   59.57,64.297 59.434,63.92 59.764,63.697 "/><polygon fill="#FFFFFF" points="55.029,49.262 55.361,49.489 55.227,49.118 55.552,48.881 55.16,48.881 55.032,48.515   54.939,48.881 54.525,48.881 54.846,49.126 54.729,49.489 "/><polygon fill="#FFFFFF" points="49.729,53.411 50.049,53.18 50.386,53.411 50.251,53.035 50.575,52.814 50.171,52.814   50.056,52.436 49.929,52.814 49.535,52.814 49.86,53.045 "/><polygon fill="#FFFFFF" points="48.231,54.445 48.107,54.068 47.993,54.445 47.591,54.438 47.908,54.675 47.793,55.045   48.117,54.814 48.431,55.045 48.305,54.68 48.631,54.438 "/><polygon fill="#FFFFFF" points="39.845,57.934 39.73,57.55 39.605,57.934 39.209,57.934 39.533,58.152 39.407,58.523 39.73,58.296   40.047,58.523 39.914,58.152 40.231,57.934 "/><polygon fill="#FFFFFF" points="38.355,53.107 38.278,52.9 38.219,53.107 37.986,53.107 38.173,53.241 38.09,53.464 38.278,53.323   38.464,53.464 38.397,53.241 38.582,53.117 "/><polygon fill="#FFFFFF" points="49.33,55.801 49.09,55.801 49.033,55.578 48.965,55.801 48.734,55.801 48.922,55.926 48.844,56.139   49.033,56.006 49.211,56.145 49.145,55.926 "/><polygon fill="#FFFFFF" points="50.042,64.369 49.969,64.146 49.913,64.363 49.676,64.369 49.867,64.493 49.794,64.708   49.969,64.575 50.154,64.715 50.089,64.493 50.285,64.369 "/></svg>
هل يصبح Chat GPT محامي في المحاكم المصرية ؟ – tahkoom.com
تفاعل

هل يصبح Chat GPT محامي في المحاكم المصرية ؟

كتبت شروق عارف

في زمن لم يعد فيه الذكاء الاصطناعي مجرد أداة ترفيهية أو وسيلة مساعدة في المهام الدراسية  بل أصبح جزءًا لا يتجزأ من تفاصيل حياتنا اليومية اقتحم هذا التطور التكنولوجي العديد من المجالات مثل الإعلام والطب والتعليم، وها هو اليوم يقترب من أبواب القانون

‏وظهر ذلك مؤخرا في قصة شاب كازاخستاني استخدم تطبيق شات جي بي تي  للطعن على مخالفة مرورية دون الاستعانة بمحامي ‏الأمر الذي جعلنا نطرح سؤال مهم هل يمكن أن نرى الذكاء الاصطناعي يوما يترافع داخل المحاكم المصرية

الذكاء الاصطناعي أداء مساعدة للمحامي وليست بديل عنه

‏صراحة أحد المحامين أن دور الذكاء الاصطناعي في المجال القانوني يجب أن يظل  محدود  ويقتصر فقد علي  تحسين النظام الإداري أو تنظيم المعلومات فإنه لا يمكن ان يعوض المحامي البشري

وأوضح  أن الذكاء الاصطناعي مجرد إلة تتلقى بيانات وتعيد إنتاجها دون أن تكون لديها قدرة على الفهم الحقيقي أو التقدير الإنساني فالذكاء الاصطناعي لا يعرف من الظالم ومن المظلوم  ولا يملك إحساسا أو ضميرا وهما عنصر أساسيان في مهنة المحاماة

 وضرب  مثالا على ذلك بقضايا القتل قائلا لو قدمت له أوراق قضية قتل  فكل ما سيفعله هو تطبيق القانون والإقرار بأن العقوبة هي الإعدام أو المؤبد لكنه لا يستطيع أن يكتشف الثغرات أو الملابسات التي قد يستخدمها المحامي للدفاع عن المتهم كما شدد على أن لكل قضية ظروفها وتفاصيلها الخاصة وهو ما لا يمكن للذكاء الاصطناعي التعامل معه بنفس كفاءة وتقدير المحامي البشري

من جانبه  قال المحامي فيصل محمد  إن الذكاء الاصطناعي قد يمثل أداة مساعدة للمحامين في بعض المهام مثل مراجعة العقود أو إعداد المذكرات القانونية لكنه لا يمكن أن يحل محل المحامي البشري خصوصا في قضايا المرافعة التي تعتمد على الفهم العميق للسياق والتقدير الشخصي للمواقف  كما اكد أن القوانين المصرية واضحة   حيث يشترط أن يكون المحامي شخص معتمدا من نقابة المحامين ولا توجد أي نصوص قانونية تسمح للذكاء الاصطناعي بالترافع أو تمثيل الموكلين أمام القضاء وأشار إلى أن تطوير استخدام الذكاء الاصطناعي في المجال القانوني يحتاج إلى تشريعات جديدة تضع ضوابط وحدودا واضحة  مؤكدا أن التكنولوجيا يمكن أن تكون مساعد  لكنها لا تستطيع أن تحل محل  المحامي في المحكمه

وفي السياق نفسه شدد المحامي محمد عاطف عبد الرسول محامي حر ومحاسب قانوني وخبير ضرائب حاصل على ماجستير في العلوم الجنائية والقضاء العسكري يري إن الاعتماد على الذكاء الاصطناعي في المجال القانوني يجب أن يكون بحذر معتبرا أن الذكاء الاصطناعي يفتقر إلى الرؤية القانوني والإدراك الأخلاقي الذي يميز المحامي البشري

‏وتابع حديثه قائلا ان القانون ليس مجرد قوانين تفسر أو تطبق، بل هو منظومة أخلاقية وإنسانية متكاملة المحامي لا يمثل فقط النص بل يمثل الضمير القانوني
الذكاء الاصطناعي لا يستطيع أن يشعر أو يتعاطف أو يقدر الملابسات النفسية والاجتماعية المحيطة بكل قضية

وأشار إلى أن استخدام الذكاء الاصطناعي في الشؤون القانونية يتطلب تنظيم تشريعي دقيق يضع له حدودا واضحة مؤكدا أن دوره يجب أن يظل مساعد وليس بديلاً خاصة في ساحات القضاء

 

‏ فعلى الرغم من التطور الملحوظ الذي حققه الذكاء الاصطناعي في مختلف المجالات لكن يبقي استخدامه كمحامي في المحاكم المصرية  موضوع  مثيرا للجدل يمكن للذكاء الاصطناعي أن يكون أداة مساعدة فعالة في بعض جوانب العمل القانوني مثل إعداد المذكرات القانونية أو تنظيم المعلومات لكن يبقى دور المحامي البشري أساسي في التحليل العميق للقضايا وفهم الظروف والملابسات

                                                                                                                                      

اظهر المزيد

مقالات ذات صلة

اترك تعليقاً

لن يتم نشر عنوان بريدك الإلكتروني. الحقول الإلزامية مشار إليها بـ *

زر الذهاب إلى الأعلى